For nearly thirty years, Art Rolnick has worked to make Minnesota the state that invests in its children first. As research director at the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis, he and Rob Grunewald showed in 2003 that money spent on the earliest years of a child’s life returns more to the public than almost any other economic development investment.
He went on to help build Minnesota’s early learning scholarships, carried the case to legislators and business leaders year after year, and is now advising other states on what has become known as the Minnesota model. Home visiting for mothers in poverty and in child protection is the next step in that work.
Kids At Risk Action (KARA) has spent more than two decades speaking for the children in Minnesota’s child protection system, and we are committed to seeing Art’s work through: bringing the voice of those children to the table, building public support, connecting partners and funders, and staying with this plan until every family that needs a home visitor has one.
Home visiting for mothers in poverty and in child protection · Nov 20, 2026 · @Mike Tikkanen
To the Governor’s Office
Minnesota can cut child abuse in half and break the cycle of child poverty within ten years, and put itself on the road to ending both. The tool is proven: trained home visitors for mothers in poverty and in child protection, starting before birth. In the Olds trials, home visiting cut child abuse and neglect by 48 percent, cut the children’s arrests by 59 percent, and left mothers less dependent on welfare. In Memphis, not one nurse-visited child died of a preventable cause by age 20.
Ten years of home visiting for every Minnesota family in child protection, phased in over three years, would cost about $2.1 billion. It would keep about 125,600 children from being abused, keep about 29,700 off the path to prison, and save 117 to 130 children’s lives. It returns $3.70 for every $1 in state spending alone, and $99 to $137 for every $1 over those children’s lifetimes.
We ask two things of the first budget:
- Fund home visiting the way Minnesota funds PreK. Permanent funding, starting with a measured rural pilot in 2027 and reaching every family in child protection by 2029. Art Rolnick has $1 million committed from business to start.
- Direct DCYF to count what Minnesota is paying for. Publish the history of every child who dies, what each placement costs and how long children stay, and what happens to children after child protection, all without identifying any family.
This plan gives the administration a goal it can measure every year and a result it can show before the end of a first term: fewer children placed, fewer emergency visits and fewer child protection cases within five years.
To Minnesota’s Legislators
Every one of your districts is already paying for child abuse. Minnesota spends $156 million to $308 million a year just to place children who have already been harmed, and it does not know the full total. It pays again in emergency rooms, special education, juvenile court and prison, for the rest of the child’s life, and then again for the next generation.
Here is the budget case, in the order a fiscal analyst would ask for it:
- The state’s own money: $3.70 back for every $1 spent, counting only health care, emergency care, special education and foster care.
- When it comes back: fewer placements, injuries and child protection cases within five years; in the Memphis trial, welfare savings alone repaid the full cost by the child’s 12th birthday.
- Justice, Jails and prisons: once the program has run a generation, prison savings alone would cover 81 to 93 percent of its yearly cost.
- The whole return: $99 to $137 for every $1 over the children’s lifetimes, and $49 to $68 even if community mentors achieve only half of what nurses achieved.
Every range in this paper is a range because Minnesota does not keep the records that would make it a number. We ask you to fund home visiting as a standing investment, like PreK, and to require the state to measure what it is paying for. The answers to the questions you will be asked are in the last sections of this paper.
To Minnesotans
More than two Minnesota children a month are dying at the hands of the people caring for them, and those are only the deaths anyone could find. Three of every four were 3 years old or younger. Most had never been in a screened-in child protection case. The system never saw them coming.
One in ten Minnesota children grows up in poverty, about 130,000 children, and for the youngest children it is higher still. Poverty does not cause abuse, but it piles on the stress that make neglect and abuse more likely. Abuse in turn makes poverty more likely for the next generation.
There is a way to break both cycles, and it starts with a neighbor. A trained, certified mentor from the mother’s own community visits her home from pregnancy through her child’s second birthday: helping with safe sleep, feeding, a toddler’s safety, the stress of a new baby, a job, the next pregnancy. It is not the government at the door. It is someone who knows the community, helping a family succeed.
Where this has been tested, it worked. Child abuse and neglect fell by 48 percent. The children were arrested 59 percent less often as teenagers. Mothers spent fewer months on welfare. And in Memphis, not one visited child died of a preventable cause by age 20.
Minnesota can do this. It costs far less than what the state already pays for abuse and trauma suffered by the child and the community; every child this reaches is a child who grows up safe.
The ten-year plan on one page
The goal: by 2036, cut child abuse in half and break the cycle of child poverty for the families most at risk, and put Minnesota on the road to ending both.
The problem. More than two Minnesota children a month are dying at the hands of the people caring for them, and those are only the deaths anyone could find.
Minnesota pays for child abuse at the most expensive end: in emergency rooms, foster care, group homes, special education, juvenile court and prison, for the rest of the child’s life, and then again for the next generation. About 130,000 Minnesota children live in poverty.
The plan. A trained and certified home visitor, in the home from pregnancy through the child’s second birthday, for every family in child protection and for mothers in poverty. Phased in over three years: one third of child protection families in 2027, two thirds in 2028, and all 22,399 from 2029 on.
What it has done where it was tested. In the Olds trials, child abuse and neglect fell by 48 percent and the children’s arrests by 59 percent. Mothers had fewer closely spaced pregnancies and spent fewer months on welfare and food stamps. In Memphis, not one nurse-visited child died of a preventable cause by age 20.
What ten years would do in Minnesota. For about $2.1 billion over ten years, home visiting would:
- Keep about 125,600 children from being abused
- Keep about 17,700 children out of foster care, group homes and residential treatment
- Keep about 29,700 children off the path to prison
- Save 117 to 130 children’s lives
What it returns, over those children’s lifetimes:
- $3.70 for every $1 in state spending on health care, emergency care, special education and foster care alone
- $42 to $80 for every $1 once crime and children’s lives are counted
- $99 to $137 for every $1 once lost health and the next generation are counted
Even at half the effect, it returns $49 to $68 for every $1. There is no other line in the state budget that comes close. The five arguments below make the case one piece at a time, and the last sections answer the hard questions and say what we ask.
Argument 1: The children who die
Safe Passage for Children of Minnesota has tracked child maltreatment deaths in this state for more than ten years. Its newest report counted 44 children killed in the 19 months from 06/01/2023 to 12/31/2024. That is more than two a month, up from about 20 a year in its earlier studies to about 28 a year now, while the number of children in Minnesota held steady. The state’s own count of deaths with a finding of maltreatment was 27 in 2024.
These are only the children we could find. Safe Passage’s first study could identify 88 of the 161 deaths the state reported; the rest were never made public. In its newest study, the state’s records did not match: some children Safe Passage found had no state report, and some state reports listed children no one else had found. Four more children were identified after the study closed.
Minnesota counts a death only when it makes a formal finding of maltreatment. A baby who dies in an unsafe bed beside an intoxicated parent, a toddler who swallows fentanyl, a child whose death is ruled accidental or undetermined: many of these deaths are misreported, underreported or never reported as maltreatment at all.
The true number is higher than anyone can say, because no one in Minnesota has been required to find out. That is changing now with recent legislation, but it will not change the misreporting of child deaths.
This is not only a Minnesota problem. In 2011, the federal Government Accountability Office found that 24 states report only the deaths of children who had previous contact with a child welfare agency, and another study found child welfare agency records undercounted deaths by 55 to 76 percent.
America does not know how many of its children are killed by the people caring for them, because many of these deaths are recorded as accidents or sudden infant death, or are never counted at all.
Who these children are. Three of every four were 3 years old or younger. Nearly two thirds died of neglect, and 1 in 5 died of fentanyl. Half of their families had been reported to child protection before, including reports that were screened out. In 2023, only 8 of the 27 children the state found had died from maltreatment had ever been in a screened-in case. Some of the rest had only screened-out reports. One 9-year-old in Hennepin County died of an untreated asthma attack after four screened-out reports.
The screening system cannot protect children it never sees. A home visitor sees them. The visitor is in the home starting before birth, in exactly the years when most of these children die, before anyone has to make a call. Unsafe sleep, drugs within a toddler’s reach, unsecured guns, a mother with a violent partner: these are what a visitor works on every week.
In the Memphis trial, which followed children for twenty years, 1.6 percent of children without a visitor died of preventable causes: sudden infant death, injuries and homicide. Among the nurse-visited children, none did.
What those lives are worth. At the 48 percent cut, phased in over three years, ten years of home visiting would save 117 to 130 children’s lives, using the state’s own low count. The CDC research values each child’s life at $16.6 million. That is $1.9 billion to $2.2 billion, about what the program costs over those ten years. Children’s lives alone would very nearly repay every dollar, before counting any other saving.
The argument: More than two Minnesota children a month are dying, and those are only the ones we know about. Home visiting is the most proven way to stop it.
Argument 2: What children in state care cost Minnesota today
This is the bill Minnesota pays right now, before a single dollar of crime, prison or adult public assistance.
In 2024, 9,891 children spent time in out-of-home care, 4,091 of them newly placed, and 1,601 were wards of the state. Placing them costs:
| Low | Middle | High | |
| One year’s new placements, statewide | $156 million | $232 million | $308 million |
| Per child placed | $38,000 | $56,600 | $75,200 |
A single stay in a group home costs about $102,900, and in residential treatment about $148,600. A year in a psychiatric residential treatment facility costs $462,000. A child stuck in a hospital bed with nowhere to go can cost several thousand dollars a day. Caseworkers, courts, guardians ad litem and medical care are not included in any of these figures; Minnesota does not publish what child protection costs in total.
How long children stay. Minnesota does not publish an average, so KARA estimated it from the state’s length-of-stay ranges. Children leaving care in 2024 had been in care about 14 months on average. Children who went home averaged about 8 months; young people who aged out averaged about 28. One in ten stays lasted three years or longer. Those are floors, because stays over three years are counted as three.
And they come back. Of children who went home, 16 percent were back in care within a year, almost twice the federal standard of 8.3 percent. In some counties it was a third or more.
What ten years of home visiting changes. At the 48 percent cut, about 17,700 fewer children would be placed over ten years.
The argument: Minnesota spends $156 million to $308 million a year to place children who have already been harmed, and many of them come back. Home visiting for every family in child protection costs $236 million a year and goes to work before the harm.
Argument 3: Crime and prison
Chief Justice Kathleen Blatz told the nation’s juvenile court judges in 2003 that 90 percent of juvenile delinquents in Hennepin County had been in child protection, and that 70 to 80 percent of prison inmates nationally had been. Child protection is where Minnesota’s prison population starts.
What one child on that path costs. A child who goes from child protection to juvenile court to prison costs Minnesota and its communities $2.66 million to $5.36 million over a lifetime: crime, victims’ losses, police, courts, prison, drug abuse and dropping out, plus health care, child protection and special education.
What Minnesota’s prisons hold. Minnesota had 8,286 adults in prison on 07/01/2025. If 70 to 80 percent came through child protection, that is about 5,800 to 6,600 people, costing $326 million to $372 million a year to operate. Over nine years at today’s population, that is $2.9 billion to $3.4 billion.
They come back. Nationally, 83 percent of people released from state prison were arrested again within 9 years, averaging 5 arrests each. For people released at 24 or younger, 84 percent were arrested within just 5 years. Youth released from Minnesota’s juvenile facility at Red Wing at 18 or older were reconvicted of a felony at 51.5 percent within three years.
What home visiting changes. The children in the Olds trials had 59 percent fewer arrests by age 15. If 1 in 4 children in Minnesota’s child protection families is headed down this path, ten years of home visiting keeps about 29,700 of them off it.
| Low | High | |
| Lifetime crime costs avoided per family served | $392,350 | $790,600 |
| Return for every $1 spent | $37 | $75 |
| Lifetime crime costs avoided, ten years of home visiting | $79 billion | $159 billion |
| Fewer people in Minnesota prisons, once the program has run a generation | 3,422 | 3,911 |
| Prison operating costs saved each year at that point | $192 million | $220 million |
Once the program has run a generation, prison savings alone would cover 81 to 93 percent of its yearly cost. At half the trial effect, the crime return is still $19 to $37 for every $1.
The argument: Minnesota pays for these children twice, first in child protection and again, for decades, in courts and prisons. Home visiting is the cheapest crime prevention the state can buy.
Argument 4: Breaking the cycle of abuse
Every cost so far prices one child. None of them prices that child’s children, and that is where abuse does its longest damage.
What the research shows. In a study of every first birth to a California teen mother in 2006 and 2007, 42.7 percent of babies whose mothers had been reported for maltreatment as children were reported themselves by age 5, against 17.8 percent of other babies of teen mothers. When the mother’s own abuse had been confirmed, her child’s risk was more than three times higher. Girls in foster care become pregnant at more than twice the rate of other girls: 71 percent by age 21 in the Midwest Study.
What Minnesota already sees. In 2024, Minnesota’s birth match system flagged 190 births to parents whose rights to an earlier child had been terminated. One in four new placements was due to a parent’s drug use, and for children under 3 it was 60 percent. Minnesota cannot say how many of today’s parents in child protection were in child protection as children, because most records are destroyed after five years.
What breaking the cycle is worth. For every four abused children kept safe, about one child in the next generation is spared a report by age 5. Priced at the average lifetime cost of an abused child, each child kept safe spares about $206,900 in the next generation. For the 125,600 children kept safe in ten years of home visiting, that is about $26 billion, or $12.20 for every $1, counting one generation only and no grandchildren.
The argument: Home visiting pays out twice: once for the child, and again for the child’s children. It is how Minnesota stops paying for the same family’s pain generation after generation.
Argument 5: Breaking the cycle of child poverty
Child abuse and child poverty feed each other. Poverty piles stress on families, and children who are abused are more likely to drop out of school, struggle to find work and raise their own children in poverty. Home visiting works on both ends: it helps mothers build steadier lives now, and it keeps children on a path out of poverty later.
How many Minnesota children are poor. About 130,000 Minnesota children, 1 in 10, live below the federal poverty line. Minnesota has made progress: the child poverty rate fell from 13.1 percent in 2015 to 10 percent in 2025. But the youngest children are the poorest, at 10.9 percent of children under 5, and those are the years home visiting reaches.
What home visiting did for mothers in the trials:
- Fewer closely spaced births. In the Memphis trial, through the child’s ninth birthday, visited mothers waited longer between their first and second children, had fewer later births, and stayed longer with their partners.
- Less time on welfare. Visited mothers in Memphis used welfare and food stamps for fewer months through age 9. Over 18 years, they cost $17,310 less in public benefits each. In Elmira, low-income unmarried mothers spent about 30 fewer months on welfare over 15 years.
- More stable families. Visited mothers in Memphis were more likely to be married from the child’s second birthday through age 18, 19.2 percent against 14.8 percent.
- Mothers’ lives. In Memphis, mothers who were not visited were eight times more likely to die of preventable causes than visited mothers.
What it does for the children. Children kept from abuse are kept off the path that runs through special education, dropping out, juvenile court and prison, the same path that leads to adult poverty. And every child kept safe is a future parent less likely to raise children in crisis.
What it will not do alone. Home visiting is not a paycheck. In the Denver trial, visited mothers worked more while the program ran, but the effect on employment did not last after it ended. Ending child poverty will take home visiting working alongside Minnesota’s other supports for families.
Home visiting adds a part no check can buy: a mother who is steadier, a child who is safe, and a family that does not pass the same trouble to the next generation.
The argument: Home visiting is where breaking the cycle of child poverty starts, before the baby is born.
Why trained community mentors
The trials used nurses. This plan uses trained, certified mentors from the mothers’ own communities, with nurse and clinical support behind them. There are three reasons.
- More visits and more families for the money. A community mentor can make 2 to 4 visits a week and carry fifteen families for about the same cost as one nurse, who serves far fewer families with far fewer visits.
- Trust opens doors. People from the community are trusted, and they open doors more easily than nurses, caseworkers and other mandated reporters. That matters most for families who fear the system, including immigrant families afraid of ICE and other families of color in the Twin Cities metro.
- Communities solving their own problems. When neighbors help neighbors, the work stops looking like the cold, hard hand of government in family affairs. It takes child protection out of the institution and puts it back in the community, where families can accept help without fearing it.
What it keeps from the nurse model. Visitors without nursing training produced about half the effect in the Denver trial. KARA’s model keeps what made nurses work: structured training, a fixed visit schedule, clinical supervision and an evaluation from the first family. Even at half the effect, the return is $49 to $68 for every $1.
KARA expects Art Rolnick’s trained community mentors will achieve or exceed the nurse model because they have personal experience of the issues and bring with them a high level of passion and commitment to help these at-risk mothers and children that they live with.
What ten years of home visiting returns
Here is the whole return in one place. Ten years of home visiting, reaching one third of Minnesota’s child protection families in 2027, two thirds in 2028 and all 22,399 from 2029 through 2036, costs about $2.1 billion at $10,547 per family. Each layer below adds to the one before it, so a reader can stop at whichever layer they trust.
| What is counted | Lifetime value | Return for every $1 |
| State budget: health care, emergency care, special education and foster care for 125,600 children kept from abuse | $7.9 billion | $3.70 |
| Plus crime: courts, prison, victims’ losses, drug abuse and dropping out, for 29,700 children kept off the path to prison | $87.0 billion to $167.3 billion | $41 to $79 |
| Plus children’s lives: 117 to 130 children who do not die | $89.0 billion to $169.5 billion | $42 to $80 |
| Plus lost health and quality of life of the children kept from abuse | $184.4 billion to $264.9 billion | $87 to $125 |
| Plus the next generation: their children spared abuse | $210.4 billion to $290.9 billion | $99 to $137 |
If home visiting by trained community mentors achieves only half of what nurses achieved, the full return is still $49 to $68 for every $1. Reducing welfare use by mothers, shown in the trials, would add to these figures but is not counted in them.
When the money comes back. Budget writers work on two-year cycles, so timing matters:
- Within five years: fewer foster placements, fewer emergency visits for injuries and fewer child protection cases return $0.70 to $3.20 of every $1.
- By the child’s 12th birthday: in the Memphis trial, welfare savings alone had repaid the full cost of the program, $12,300 against $11,511 per family.
- By age 18: Nurse-Family Partnership’s cost models put government savings at $2.65 to $3.10 for every $1; RAND found $5.70 for the highest-risk families.
- By age 20: in Memphis, no nurse-visited child had died of a preventable cause.
- Over 40 years and into the next generation: $99 to $137 for every $1.
The argument: Home visiting is not a cost Minnesota carries. It is money Minnesota gets back, first within a dozen years and then many times over, while children who would have died grow up.
Answers to the hard questions
“Most alleged victims aren’t abused children.” The figures above count every child reported and assessed, 29,072 in 2024, because Minnesota’s own count of confirmed cases is a floor by design: two thirds of cases go to Family Assessment, where no finding of maltreatment is ever made. Counting only the 4,487 children with a confirmed finding, the lifetime return is still $48 to $86 for every $1.
“Most of that money isn’t in the state budget.” True for the later layers, which include victims’ losses and lost quality of life. That is why the first layer stands alone: $3.70 for every $1 in state spending on health care, special education and foster care, and $2.65 to $3.10 by age 18 in Nurse-Family Partnership’s own models. Once the program has run a generation, prison savings alone cover most of its yearly cost.
“The trials studied first-time mothers, not child protection families.” True. That is why Minnesota should aim the program the way the evidence supports: first-time mothers in poverty, reached before birth, and child protection families with a new baby. The rural pilot in 2027 will measure the results on Minnesota families.
“Community mentors aren’t nurses.” Visitors without nursing training produced about half the effect in the Denver trial, and at half the effect the return is still $49 to $68 for every $1. Community mentors can also reach more families, open doors nurses cannot, and take the cold hand of government out of family life. See “Why trained community mentors” above.
“Home visiting won’t end poverty by itself.” True. It helps mothers spend less time on welfare and space their children, and it keeps children on a path out of poverty, but it works best alongside Minnesota’s other supports for families. That is why the goal is to break the cycle within ten years and end child poverty over the long run.
“The savings take decades.” Some do. But foster placements, emergency visits and child protection cases fall within the first five years, and in Memphis the program had paid for itself in welfare savings by the time the children were 12. That is why it should be funded the way Minnesota funds PreK: as a standing investment, not a one-time grant.
“Can Minnesota really reach every family?” Not every family will say yes, and the projections should be scaled to the enrollment the pilot achieves. A smaller number that holds up is worth more than a bigger one that does not.
“Why should we trust your numbers?” Don’t. Have Minnesota run them. The state does not follow children from child protection into schools, emergency rooms, juvenile court or prison, and it does not publish the history of the children who die. Every range in this paper is a range because Minnesota does not keep the records that would make it a number. We want to see those numbers.
What we ask
Set the goal. Commit Minnesota to cutting child abuse in half and breaking the cycle of child poverty by 2036, and report progress to the public every year.
Fund home visiting the way Minnesota funds PreK. Permanent, statewide funding for trained home visiting mentors for families in poverty and in child protection, phased in over three years and starting with a measured rural pilot in 2027. Art Rolnick has $1 million committed from business to start.
KARA’s community mentor model is designed to cost less than Nurse-Family Partnership’s $10,547 per family: Every return in this paper goes up if it does.
Require Minnesota to count what it is paying for. Direct DCYF to publish, every year:
- For every child who dies or suffers egregiously from maltreatment, whether there were prior reports, and whether they were screened out, sent to Family Assessment or investigated. Children whose reports are screened out should be followed up at least once before they are dropped from the data.
- What a day costs in each placement setting, how long children stay in each, how many state wards are in each, and how many return to some form of CPS, welfare, or justice system involvement after they leave.
- What happens to children after child protection, by linking child protection records to school, emergency care, public assistance, juvenile court and prison records, with Minn-LInK at the University of Minnesota as a ready partner. This is deidentified data and should be trackable and reportable.
Fix the privacy problem without exposing families. There is a recurring problem in data collection that will need to be solved to reach meaningful child outcome data. Today, conflicting and confusing privacy and safety laws give institutions a powerful reason not to report. Part of our ask is to investigate thoroughly how to reach those numbers without identifying families who are already suffering.
Minnesota can track these children without exposing any of them: link the records inside a secure research partner such as Minn-LInK at the University of Minnesota, remove names and identifying details before any data leaves it, and publish only totals, holding back any count small enough to point to a particular child or family, as DCYF already does when a number falls below seven.
Minnesota cannot save money it does not measure, and it cannot protect children it does not count.
Sources and assumptions
Minnesota data
- Children in care, placements, state wards, length of stay and reentry: Minnesota’s Out-of-home Care and Permanency Report, 2024, DCYF, 08/15/2026.
- Reports, findings, alleged victims, deaths and the birth match: Minnesota’s Child Maltreatment Report, 2024, DCYF, 08/15/2026; prior screened-in cases among children who died: Minnesota’s Child Maltreatment Report, 2023.
- Group home and residential treatment rates: DHS Title IV-E per diem report, effective 01/01/2026.
- Prison population, per diem and recidivism: Department of Corrections 2025 Performance Report.
- Chief Justice Blatz: address to the National Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges, 07/22/2003.
Child poverty
- Children in poverty, 130,000 and 10 percent: Annie E. Casey Foundation KIDS COUNT Data Center, 2023, from the American Community Survey.
- Child poverty from 13.1 percent in 2015 to 10 percent in 2025: USAFacts, from the American Community Survey.
- Children under 5 in poverty, 10.9 percent: Minnesota Department of Health, American Community Survey 2020 to 2024.
- Mothers’ outcomes through age 9 in Memphis: Olds and colleagues, 2007, Pediatrics. Over 18 years: Kitzman and colleagues, 2019, JAMA Network Open. Elmira welfare months: Olds and colleagues, JAMA 1997. Mothers’ mortality: University of Rochester, 2014.
Child deaths
- Safe Passage for Children of Minnesota, Child Fatalities from Maltreatment 2023 to 2024, 01/2026, and the 2014 to 2022 study.
- Undercounting of child maltreatment deaths nationally: U.S. Government Accountability Office, 2011.
- Memphis mortality results: Olds and colleagues, 2014, JAMA Pediatrics.
Research
- Abuse costs per child and the value of a child’s life: Peterson, Florence and Klevens, 2018, 2015 dollars; breakdown from Health Policy Institute of Ohio.
- Crime costs: Cohen and Piquero, 2009, 2007 dollars.
- Recidivism: Bureau of Justice Statistics, 9-year follow-up and 5-year patterns.
- Generational abuse: Putnam-Hornstein and colleagues, 2014; Midwest Study.
- Home visiting results and costs: Brookings summary of the trials; Olds and colleagues, JAMA 1997 and JAMA 1998; Memphis age-12 follow-up, 2006 dollars, discounted; Nurse-Family Partnership cost models for Oregon and New York; RAND estimate.
KARA’s assumptions
- Program. $10,547 per family for 22,399 families, phased in: one third in 2027, two thirds in 2028, all from 2029 through 2036. Total about $2.1 billion over ten years, in 2017 dollars, held flat.
- Effects. 48 percent fewer cases of abuse and neglect and 59 percent fewer arrests, from the Olds trials, applied at Minnesota’s 2024 levels. Half-effect figures cut both in half.
- Children counted. 29,072 alleged victims, 4,091 children placed and 27 to 30 deaths a year. Confirmed-only figures use the 4,487 children with a finding.
- State budget layer. Per abused child: $46,503 in health care including emergency care and $8,693 in special education; plus $56,600 per child placed.
- Crime. 1 in 4 children in served families on the path to prison, at $2.66 million to $5.36 million each. The 70 to 80 percent share of prisoners from child protection is Blatz’s 2003 national figure. Prison operations at $153.81 a day.
- Lives. $16.6 million per child’s life.
- Lost health and quality of life. $760,000 per abused child, the research’s value for lost health and quality of life.
- Next generation. One generation, one child per parent, reports by age 5, at $830,928 per child.
- Poverty. Savings from mothers’ reduced welfare use are described but not added to the returns.
- Not adjusted. Dollar years range from 2006 to 2026 and, except for the Memphis figures, are not adjusted or discounted.
- Extrapolation. The trials enrolled first-time mothers during pregnancy, so applying their results to every family in child protection is an extrapolation.
To save children, money, and our communities, share this plan widely and make sure to send it to your state representative and senator (FIND THEM HERE) and ask them to fund home visiting the way Minnesota funds PreK.
SUPPORT KARA’s EFFORTS TO MAKE THIS HAPPEN FOR MINNESOTA CHILDREN HERE








