These 3 stories provide a snapshot of the real cost of crime in America today: It Can’t Happen Here (Sally’s Story) – INVISIBLE CHILDREN
and, When Is Child Abuse a Crime ? – INVISIBLE CHILDREN
What Crime Really Costs America: Up to $6 Trillion a Year, and Most of It Is Paid in Pain
[OPENING STORY – a specific case from Mike’s files or Invisible Children. One child, one moment, what it cost them and the people around them.]
We talk about crime in counts. Arrests, incidents, rates per 100,000. Counts are useful, but they hide the bill. And the bill is enormous.
The range: $2.2 trillion to nearly $6 trillion a year
There is no single official number for what crime costs the United States. There are several serious attempts, and they land in different places because they count different things. A 2017 review by the Government Accountability Office found published estimates ranging from $690 billion to $3.41 trillion a year. Newer work has pushed the top of that range higher.
| Study | Data year | Annual cost | What it counts |
| Miller, Cohen and others, Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis (2021) | 2017 | $2.6 trillion (likely range $2.2-$3.0 trillion) | Personal and property crimes against people, including pain, suffering and lost quality of life |
| Anderson, Journal of Law and Economics (2021) | Recent years | $2.86-$3.92 trillion, or $4.71-$5.76 trillion counting stolen money and property | Adds the cost of fear, private security, and time spent avoiding crime |
| GAO review (2017) | Various | $690 billion to $3.41 trillion | Summary of earlier national estimates |
The most widely cited figure is $2.6 trillion. Researchers led by Ted Miller and Mark Cohen counted more than 120 million crimes in 2017, 24 million of them violent. Only $620 billion of the total was out-of-pocket: police, courts, prisons, hospitals, victim services, child welfare proceedings, and stolen or damaged property. That alone is about $1,900 for every person in the country, more than the nation spent on the military that year.
The other $1.95 trillion was quality of life. Pain. Fear. Grief. Lives cut short. Violent crime made up 85% of the total.
And that $2.6 trillion is the conservative number. It leaves out most white-collar and corporate crime, crimes against businesses, and what we all spend on locks, alarms, and avoiding certain streets. Economist David Anderson counted those things too. His estimate runs as high as $5.76 trillion a year.
Why the human cost is real money, not a guess
Some readers will see “pain and suffering” and think it is soft. It is not. It is the same math our legal system and federal government already use every day.
When a federal agency decides whether a safety rule is worth the cost, it puts a dollar value on a death prevented. The U.S. Department of Transportation’s current “value of a statistical life” is $14.2 million. Other agencies, including Homeland Security, use DOT’s figure.
Courts do the same thing case by case. Juries award damages for pain, suffering, and the loss of a family member. Insurers pay those settlements. When Mark Cohen built the first modern cost-of-crime estimates for the Justice Department, he used jury awards from personal injury cases to put a value on the pain, suffering, and fear crime victims live with. The trillion-dollar totals above rest on that foundation.
So when a study says a murder or a rape costs society millions, it is not being dramatic. It is using the same yardstick a courtroom or a federal regulator would.
Losing someone: the cost families carry
Miller and Cohen found that the cost of violent crime is driven mostly by lost wages, lost household work, and lost quality of life for victims and their families. Families are inside the number, not outside it.
The research on what happens to them is hard to read. In a five-year study of parents whose children died violently, parents whose children were murdered were twice as likely to meet the full criteria for PTSD as parents who lost a child to an accident or suicide. Five years later, 27.7% of the mothers still met the criteria, roughly three times the normal rate.
When one parent kills the other, children lose both at once: one to death, one to prison or flight. A review of the research on these children found lasting mental health and wellbeing problems, shaped by things like whether the child saw it happen and whether the two families end up fighting over the child.
Gun violence alone, including suicides, carries an estimated $557 billion a year in costs. That works out to $1.34 billion every day in lost quality of life for victims and their families.
Carjacking: the crime where kids now match adults
Carjacking is one of the crimes that has frightened communities most since 2020. The FBI does not track it as its own category, so the best national picture comes from the Council on Criminal Justice, which studied 10 large cities.
Here is what it found:
- The average carjacking rate in those cities nearly doubled, from 20.1 per 100,000 people in 2018 to 37.9 in 2023.
- The juvenile carjacking rate rose 59% from 2018 to 2022. The adult rate rose 33%. By 2022 the juvenile rate (19.8) was slightly higher than the adult rate (18.6).
- For robbery and car theft, adults offend at much higher rates than juveniles. Carjacking is different. Kids do it at about the same rate as adults.
- 62% of carjackings involved a gun in 2022. About 28% injured the victim. There were 1.7 homicides for every 1,000 carjackings.
- Only about 24% of carjackings were cleared by police.
Two honest caveats. The Council found that juveniles did not drive the rise by themselves; the adult and juvenile rates moved together. In MN it was juveniles that shot the man trying to get his two year old out of the back seat of the car and 12 and 13 year olds that beat up the old woman trying to keep her purse.
Why would a 14-year-old point a gun at a stranger for a car?
Where many of these kids come from
This is where the cost of crime and the cost of child abuse become the same conversation.
In a landmark National Institute of Justice study, researchers followed 908 children with court-substantiated abuse or neglect and compared them with similar children who were not maltreated. Being abused or neglected increased the chance of arrest as a juvenile by 59%, as an adult by 28%, and for a violent crime by 30%. The maltreated kids were arrested younger and committed nearly twice as many offenses.
Minnesota has seen this up close. Former Minnesota Supreme Court Chief Justice Kathleen Blatz has stated that 90% of the youth in our juvenile justice system passed through child protection first. And for twenty years, nine-year recidivism for those youth has stayed at around 80%. [SOURCE: link or date and venue of Justice Blatz’s statement]
The same researchers who built the $2.6 trillion estimate also asked what it is worth to turn one high-risk kid around. A youth with six or more police contacts imposes $3.2 to $5.8 million in costs over a lifetime. Saving one at age 14 is worth $2.6 to $5.3 million to society. And a small group, about 6% of juvenile offenders, commits about half of all juvenile crime.
We know who many of these kids are before they ever steal a car. A lot of them are already in the child protection system.
The cost of child abuse itself
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention puts the lifetime cost of a single case of nonfatal child maltreatment at $830,928. A child who dies from abuse or neglect: $16.6 million.
For one year of substantiated cases, 482,000 children who lived and 1,670 who did not, the lifetime cost came to $428 billion. Counting every child investigated for maltreatment that year, the CDC estimate reaches $2 trillion. That is from 2015 data. A later analysis of 2018 substantiated cases put the figure at $563 billion.
Why an American child has less to stand on
Every nation in the world except the United States has ratified the UN Rights of the Child Treaty. We helped write it. We signed it. No president has ever sent it to the Senate.
That matters because the treaty makes children rights holders, people with their own claim on the law, not the property of their parents. And other nations have acted on it. Seventy countries now make it illegal to hit a child, including at home. In the United States, hitting your child is legal in every state. How other nations make it a crime to beat a child
Here, a child has no standing of their own in court. Children can rarely hire a lawyer, or even find one willing to bring their case. So nothing happens unless a prosecutor acts, and parents are very rarely charged. In thirty years of child protection work I have seen it over and over: the abuser stays in the home and no charges are ever filed. Child abuse is a crime on paper. In practice we almost never treat it like one.
There is a cost to that, too. The child pays it first. Then the rest of us pay it, in hospital bills, special education, foster care, juvenile court, prisons, and the next generation of victims.
The biggest number of all: $14.1 trillion
One study belongs apart from the crime totals, because it measures something different and cannot be added to them. But it may be the most important number in this post.
In 2023, CDC researchers published a study in JAMA Network Open on adverse childhood experiences, or ACEs. ACEs include abuse and neglect, and also growing up with violence in the home, a parent in prison, or a household member with addiction or mental illness.
The findings:
- 63% of American adults, about 160 million people, had at least one ACE.
- The health conditions tied to those experiences cost $14.1 trillion a year: $183 billion in medical care and $13.9 trillion in lost years of healthy life.
- That is $88,000 per affected adult every year, and $2.4 million over a lifetime.
- Adults with four or more ACEs, 22% of the population, carry 58% of the burden. Their lifetime cost is about $4 million each.
That is not a crime statistic. It is what happens to children’s bodies and lives when we do not protect them, measured decades later.
What would actually change it
The numbers point in one direction. The cheapest crime is the one that never happens, and the earliest place to stop it is in a child’s first years. [Mike: name the specific KARA programs or policies you want readers to support – prenatal home visiting, trauma-trained mentors, CRC ratification.]
Prevention costs money. Every study above says not preventing it costs far more. We are already paying. We are just paying at the wrong end.
KIDS AT RISK ACTION / KARA / INVISIBLE CHILDREN
This post submitted by former CASA volunteer Mike Tikkanen
Sources
Total cost of crime
- Miller, Cohen, Swedler, Ali and Hendrie, Incidence and Costs of Personal and Property Crimes in the USA, 2017, Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis (2021). Summary: Vanderbilt University news release, 02/05/2021
- Anderson, The Aggregate Cost of Crime in the United States, Journal of Law and Economics (2021)
- U.S. Government Accountability Office, Costs of Crime (2017)
Valuing death, injury and suffering
- U.S. Department of Transportation, Guidance on Valuation of a Statistical Life ($14.2 million, base year 2025)
- Cohen, Cost of Crime to Victims, U.S. Department of Justice (1986) – jury awards used to value pain and suffering
- Murphy and others, PTSD Among Bereaved Parents Following the Violent Deaths of Their Children, Journal of Traumatic Stress (1999)
- Murphy and others, The Prevalence of PTSD Following the Violent Death of a Child and Predictors of Change 5 Years Later, Journal of Traumatic Stress (2003)
- Alisic and others, Children’s Mental Health and Wellbeing after Parental Intimate Partner Homicide, Clinical Child and Family Psychology Review (2015)
- Everytown for Gun Safety Support Fund, The Economic Cost of Gun Violence (2022) – advocacy group, built with economist Ted Miller; includes suicides
Carjacking and juveniles
- Council on Criminal Justice, Trends in Carjacking: What You Need to Know (12/2024)
- The Sentencing Project, letter to Senate Judiciary Committee citing CCJ carjacking decline (04/28/2026)
- Widom and Maxfield, An Update on the “Cycle of Violence”, National Institute of Justice (2001)
- Cohen and Piquero, New Evidence on the Monetary Value of Saving a High Risk Youth, Journal of Quantitative Criminology (2009)
Child maltreatment and childhood adversity
- Peterson, Florence and Klevens, The Economic Burden of Child Maltreatment in the United States, 2015, Child Abuse and Neglect (2018)
- Chapin Hall, A Preventable Cost: Economic Burden of Child Maltreatment (06/2024)
- Peterson and others, Economic Burden of Health Conditions Associated With Adverse Childhood Experiences Among US Adults, JAMA Network Open (12/2023)
Children’s rights and the law
- ACLU, There’s Only One Country That Hasn’t Ratified the Convention on Children’s Rights: US
- End Corporal Punishment, Countdown to Universal Prohibition – 70 countries with a full ban, including in the home
- KARA, [summary of how other nations make it a crime to beat a child – ADD LINK]
- Kathleen Blatz, former Chief Justice, Minnesota Supreme Court – [ADD LINK OR DATE AND VENUE OF STATEMENT]
- Mike Tikkanen, firsthand experience in child protection (standing, attorneys, charging, abusers remaining in the home)
As of 10/09/2026, every number in both posts comes from a linked source or is attributed by name to the person who stated it.








